---
title: "One Garage Door Spring Broke: Should You Replace Both?"
description: "One of two garage door springs broke? Single-car doors usually use one spring, two-car doors two. Why a pair is replaced together and how to tell yours."
url: "https://farnsworthgarage.com/one-garage-door-spring-broke-should-you-replace-both/"
type: "post"
published: "2026-11-11T22:00:00Z"
modified: "2026-11-11T22:00:00Z"
author: "Riley Farnsworth"
publisher: "Farnsworth Garage Door Service, Mesa, AZ"
phone: "(602) 935-9766"
---
# One Garage Door Spring Broke: Should You Replace Both?

![Two torsion springs on the bar above a garage door, split by the center bracket. The spring on the right is broken, with a gap in its coils, while the spring on the left is still in one piece.](https://farnsworthgarage.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/snapped-torsion-spring.png.opt.webp)

Quick Answer

If your door has two torsion springs and one broke, replace both as a matched pair. The two springs have lifted the same door the same number of times, so the one still hanging there is worn too, and a new spring paired with an old one won't lift evenly.

-   **Two-spring door** (most two-car garage doors): replace both, matched to each other and to the door's weight.
-   **One-spring door** (most single-car garage doors): only that spring needs replacing. Ask whether a heavy door should be converted to two.
-   **Don't use the door in the meantime.** The spring that's left is carrying more than its share.

### In Phoenix, Mesa or Gilbert? Send us a photo of your springs.

Take it from the floor, without touching anything. We'll tell you whether your door has one spring or two and what a matched replacement includes, in writing before any work starts.

[Schedule a free estimate](https://farnsworthgarage.com/book-appointment-now/)[Text us a photo of your springs](sms:+16029359766)

Serving Phoenix, Mesa, Gilbert, Chandler, Scottsdale, Tempe and Queen Creek

It's one of the most common questions we get on spring calls: "Only one of them broke. Can't you just replace that one?" It sounds like it should save money. On a two-spring door, it usually just moves the second service call a few months down the road.

This guide explains why the second spring is close behind, why a new spring and an old spring don't make a good pair, when one spring really is enough, and how to tell what your door has. If a spring just broke and you haven't decided anything yet, start with [what to do about a broken garage door spring](https://farnsworthgarage.com/broken-garage-door-spring-how-to-spot-it-and-what-it-costs-to-fix-in-arizona/). For what the repair costs, see our [spring repair cost guide](https://farnsworthgarage.com/garage-door-spring-repair-cost-arizona/).

## How Many Springs Does Your Garage Door Have?

Start here, because the answer decides everything else in this guide. **A single-car garage door usually uses one spring. A two-car garage door usually uses two.** A two-car door is wider and heavier, so its weight is split between two springs, one on each side of a center bracket.

| Garage door | Usual number of springs | If one spring breaks |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Single-car (about 8 or 9 feet wide) | One | Replace that spring. Ask whether a heavy door should be converted to two. |
| Two-car (about 16 feet wide) | Two | Replace both as a matched pair. |

These are the usual setups, not a rule. A heavy single-car door can have two springs, and some older two-car doors were built with one. To know for sure, check from the floor. Don't climb up to it and don't touch anything.

1.  **Look at the metal bar above the closed door.** Torsion springs are the tightly wound coils on that bar. You'll see one coil, or two coils with a bracket in the middle between them.
2.  **Look for a gap.** A broken torsion spring usually shows a gap of a couple of inches where the coil separated.
3.  **Take a photo** from where you're standing. It helps whoever comes out bring the right parts.

## Why Is the Second Spring Close Behind?

Springs wear out by cycles. One cycle is one trip up and one trip down. Most standard residential torsion springs are rated for about 10,000 cycles. On a two-spring door, both springs share every one of those cycles, so they wear at the same pace.

Here's how that works out for a typical household. These are **illustration numbers, not measurements**. Your door's real rating and how often it runs will differ.

| Door use | Cycles a year | Years to reach 10,000 cycles |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Opened and closed 2 times a day | About 730 | About 13.7 |
| Opened and closed 4 times a day | About 1,460 | About 6.8 |
| Opened and closed 6 times a day (garage is the front door) | About 2,190 | About 4.6 |

Assumptions: a 10,000-cycle spring and the same number of cycles every day of the year. The table shows the pattern. It doesn't predict when your spring will break.

Springs don't fail at exactly the same cycle. Small differences in the steel decide which one goes first. But when one has reached the end of its life, the other has done the same work and is near the end of its own. That's why the spring that's still in place is no reason to relax.

How long your springs last also depends on the spring's cycle rating and how well the door is balanced and maintained. Our [spring lifespan guide](https://farnsworthgarage.com/garage-door-spring-lifespan-how-10000-cycle-25000-cycle-and-50000-cycle-springs-compare/) compares the cycle ratings.

## Can You Replace Just One Spring?

On a two-spring door, we don't recommend it, and we don't do it. Three problems come with a mismatched pair:

-   **The springs won't match.** The two springs on a door are a set: the same wire size, inside diameter, length and winding, chosen together for that door's weight. A new spring next to one that's lost some of its strength over thousands of cycles isn't a match anymore, even if the part numbers are the same.
-   **The door lifts unevenly.** The stronger new spring does more of the work. The door can lift crooked, wear one cable and one side of the hardware faster, and make the opener work harder.
-   **The old spring is still due.** You've paid for a service call, and the spring that's left is near the end of its life. When it goes, it's another call, often at a worse time.

Replacing both together costs more than one spring, but less than two separate visits, because the trip, the setup and the balancing only happen once. Our [spring repair cost guide](https://farnsworthgarage.com/garage-door-spring-repair-cost-arizona/) breaks down what goes into the price.

**This is not a DIY job.** Torsion springs hold enough stored energy to cause serious injury. Don't loosen, wind or remove a spring, and don't try to lift a door with a broken spring by hand. Leave it closed and call a trained technician.

### Only one spring broke? Get a quote for the matched pair.

If you're in Phoenix, Mesa, Gilbert, Chandler or nearby, leave the door closed and send us a photo of your springs from the floor. We'll tell you what your door needs and put it in writing before any work starts.

[Schedule a free estimate](https://farnsworthgarage.com/book-appointment-now/)[Call or text (602) 935-9766](tel:+16029359766)

Serving Mesa, Gilbert, Chandler, Queen Creek and the Phoenix area

## Are Two Garage Door Springs Better Than One?

As covered above, single-car doors usually use one spring and two-car doors usually use two. Two springs split the door's weight, so each one does half the lifting, which is why heavier doors, like a two-car insulated door, almost always use two.

There's a safety difference too:

-   **On a one-spring door,** the door won't open at all once that spring breaks. It's obvious right away, and the door stays put.
-   **On a two-spring door,** the spring that's left may still move the door partway. That's the risky version: the door lifts crooked or feels heavy, and people keep using it. If your door tilts or one side lags, see our guide to a [crooked or tilted garage door](https://farnsworthgarage.com/why-is-my-garage-door-crooked-or-tilted-cable-drum-diagnosis/), and don't run it.

Some heavier doors were built with a single spring. When we replace one, we'll tell you whether converting the door to two springs makes sense for its weight. It's your call, and it'll be on the written quote as an option.

## What a Matched Spring Replacement Includes

Whoever you hire, a two-spring replacement should cover more than the springs themselves. Here's what ours includes:

-   **Both springs matched to the door.** Sized to the door's actual weight, not just copied from the old part.
-   **A look at the parts the break can damage.** We check the cables, drums, bearings and rollers. A spring break often frays a cable, and we'll show you anything that needs attention.
-   **A cycle-rating choice.** Standard springs, or higher-cycle springs that last longer for a busy household. We explain both and you choose.
-   **Balance and safety tests.** The door should stay put about halfway up with the opener released, and the opener's safety reverse is tested before we leave.
-   **A written quote before any work.** It lists how many springs, the cycle rating, and whether cables or other parts are included.

If you live in Phoenix, Mesa, Gilbert, Chandler or nearby, our [spring repair service](https://farnsworthgarage.com/garage-door-repair-service-installation/garage-door-spring-repair/) page has more on how we work.

### Ready to replace the pair?

We match both springs to your door's weight, check the cables, drums and bearings, balance the door and test the opener's safety reverse. You get a written quote before any work begins.

[Schedule a free estimate](https://farnsworthgarage.com/book-appointment-now/)[Call or text (602) 935-9766](tel:+16029359766)

Serving Mesa, Gilbert, Chandler, Queen Creek and the Phoenix area

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Should I replace both garage door springs if only one broke?

Yes, if your door has two torsion springs. Both springs have done the same number of cycles, so the one still in place is near the end of its life. A new spring paired with a worn one won't lift evenly. Replacing both together avoids a second service call and keeps the door balanced.

### How many springs does a garage door have?

A single-car garage door usually has one torsion spring. A two-car garage door usually has two, one on each side of a center bracket. Heavier doors can have two even when they're narrower, so check the bar above your door to be sure.

### Can I replace just one garage door spring?

Only if your door was built with a single spring. On a two-spring door, replacing one leaves a new spring next to a worn one. The door can lift unevenly, the opener works harder, and the old spring is still due to break.

### Are two garage door springs better than one?

For wider, heavier doors, yes. Single-car garage doors usually use one spring and two-car garage doors usually use two, because two springs share the weight of a bigger door. The trade-off is that a door can sometimes still move on one remaining spring, so people keep using a door that isn't safe. If one of two springs breaks, stop using the door.

### How long do garage door springs last?

Standard torsion springs are commonly rated for about 10,000 cycles, where one cycle is one trip up and down. How many years that takes depends on how often the door runs. A door that runs a few times a day might reach it in roughly 7 to 10 years, and one used as the main entry, sooner. Higher-cycle springs last longer.

### Does replacing both springs cost twice as much as one?

No. It costs more than a single spring, but the trip, the setup and the balancing only happen once, so it costs less than two separate repairs. Ask for a written quote that lists how many springs are being replaced and their cycle rating.

### Why is my garage door crooked after one spring broke?

When one of two springs breaks, the other side is still pulling, so the door can lift unevenly. A crooked door can also mean a cable slipped off its drum. Either way, stop using the door and leave it where it is until a technician checks it.

![Riley Farnsworth, co-owner of Farnsworth Garage Door Service in Mesa, Arizona](https://farnsworthgarage.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/rileyfarnsworthportrait-copy.opt-480.webp)

Written by

[Riley Farnsworth](https://farnsworthgarage.com/about-farnsworth-garage-door-services/)

Co-Owner, Farnsworth Garage Door Service

Riley has helped Arizona homeowners with garage door repair, spring replacement, opener installation, and garage door replacement throughout Mesa and the surrounding Phoenix area.

[More articles by Riley](https://farnsworthgarage.com/blog/)[LinkedIn](https://www.linkedin.com/in/rileyfarnsworth/)

## One Spring Down? Let's Replace the Pair.

Licensed and insured in Arizona (ROC #351810), locally owned in Mesa, serving Phoenix, Gilbert, Chandler, Scottsdale, Tempe and Queen Creek. You get a written quote before any work begins.

[Schedule a Free Estimate](https://farnsworthgarage.com/book-appointment-now/) [Call / Text (602) 935-9766](tel:+16029359766) [Text Us a Photo](sms:+16029359766)

---
Source: https://farnsworthgarage.com/one-garage-door-spring-broke-should-you-replace-both/ · HTML version with images, galleries and booking form. Farnsworth Garage Door Service, Mesa, AZ · (602) 935-9766
